Score 84/100 · Order: Cherry Garcia or Phish Food · $5–8
Ben & Jerry's is the national benchmark for a reason. The flavors are creative, the ingredients are high-quality, and the consistency is reliable across locations. Cherry Garcia and Phish Food are still excellent, and the newer rotating flavors keep the menu interesting. The texture is good but not as dense as the local premium shops. It is a solid option when you are in an area without a local favorite, or when you want a flavor you already know you love.