We use cookies for essential site functions and, with your permission, for analytics and advertising. California residents can opt out of the sale or sharing of personal information at any time. See our Privacy Policy, Cookie Policy, and Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information.
Where to buy, rent, and DIY the best Halloween costumes in San Diego — from vintage thrift shops to dedicated costume rental stores.
Last updated
For a one-time polished costume, rent from Costume Ville or The Harem & Co. For budget DIY, thrift at Buffalo Exchange and the Hillcrest shops. For last-minute kids' costumes, Party City is reliable but crowded the final week.
Year-round costume shop
4101 El Cajon Blvd, City Heights
$25–$80 rental; $30–$100 purchase
Best for: Full costumes, wigs, accessories, rentals
Large inventory and helpful staff. One of the few dedicated costume shops in the city open year-round.
Boutique costume rental
Kearny Mesa / online
$50–$200 rental
Best for: High-quality period pieces, burlesque, drag
Known for detailed vintage and theatrical costumes. Book early for Halloween — popular items go fast.
Nonprofit thrift store
Hillcrest
$5–$25
Best for: Vintage clothing, jackets, quirky accessories
Hillcrest has several thrift stores within walking distance — this is the best starting point for DIY costume pieces.
Resale clothing chain
Multiple: Hillcrest, Pacific Beach, North Park
$10–$40
Best for: Trendy secondhand outfits, statement pieces
Buy, sell, trade. Great for last-minute costumes that look intentional rather than off-the-rack.
Thrift superstore
Multiple locations countywide
$3–$20
Best for: Budget DIY costumes, suits, dresses, props
The best selection is at larger suburban locations (Mission Valley, Kearny Mesa). Halloween sections pop up in October.
Curated vintage boutique
South Park
$30–$120
Best for: 1950s–1980s authentic looks
Small but well-curated. Perfect for vintage icons, pin-up, and retro group costumes.
Coastal vintage and plant shop
Solana Beach
$20–$80
Best for: Boho, coastal, and beachy costume pieces
A North County option for anyone who wants a less city-center thrifting experience.
Big-box costume retailer
Multiple: Mission Valley, San Marcos, Chula Vista
$20–$80
Best for: Mass-market licensed costumes, accessories, makeup
Reliable for kids' costumes and last-minute needs. Expect lines the week before Halloween.
Use a thrifted Hawaiian shirt, board shorts, and a toy shark clipped to the leg. Add fake blood for a shark-attack twist.
Shop it: Buffalo Exchange + any dollar store
Brown and gold everything — a vintage Padres cap, jersey, and sunglasses. Easy, recognizable, and warm enough for an October night.
Shop it: Goodwill or Padres Team Store
A Victorian-style dress, a single red rose, and pale makeup. Great for a haunted, historic San Diego reference.
Shop it: Harem & Co. or Frock You Vintage
Cardboard, felt, and hot-glue a giant taco shell. Wear all brown with a foil 'burrito' wrapper. San Diego-specific and cheap.
Shop it: Goodwill + craft stores
Khaki shorts, a polo, a whistle, and a plush orca. Swap for a pirate version with an eye patch and a plastic sword.
Shop it: Party City or thrift store
The best vintage pieces and jackets get picked over by early October. Hillcrest and North Park thrift stores start putting Halloween items front-and-center by mid-September.
Costume Ville and The Harem & Co. rent high-quality outfits. It's cheaper than buying a $80 mass-market costume you'll wear once.
The best combo is thrifted base clothing + new accessories (wigs, hats, makeup, props). That split keeps costs low and the look unique.
People sell barely-used costumes for half price after Halloween. Shop the first week of November for next year's costume at 50% off.
Costume Ville in City Heights and The Harem & Co. are dedicated costume shops. For budget options, hit Buffalo Exchange, Hillcrest thrift stores, and Goodwill. Party City is the easiest chain for last-minute licensed costumes.
Hillcrest, North Park, and South Park have the densest clusters of thrift and vintage stores. Buffalo Exchange, Hillcrest Thrift Shop, Frock You Vintage, and Goodwill are the best starting points.
Yes — Costume Ville on El Cajon Blvd and The Harem & Co. both rent costumes. Expect $25–$200 depending on the quality and complexity of the costume.
Surfer, Padres fan, California burrito, sea lion or orca, Kate Morgan from the Hotel del Coronado, or a Tijuana day-tripper. Lean into the beach, Mexican-American culture, and local haunted history.
Shop thrift stores by mid-September for the best selection. Party City and big-box stores are fine through mid-October, but the most popular sizes sell out the last week.
Yes — Gaslamp clubs, Hillcrest's Nightmare on Normal Street, Little Italy Halloween Wine Walk, and many neighborhood bars run cash-prize costume contests. See our San Diego Halloween bars guide for the full list.
The Sandi Spots Newsletter
New beach finds, hidden taco shops, weekend events, and seasonal guides — once a week from a local. No spam, ever.
One email a week. Unsubscribe anytime.
Written and fact-checked by the Sandi Spots Editorial team — San Diego residents publishing under Sleep Coast LLC. Every place we recommend has been visited in person or verified against an official source, and no business can pay for inclusion or a higher ranking. Last updated .