Order: Sofia (burrata + prosciutto), Regina Margherita $16–$24
AVPN-certified Neapolitan; consistently ranked #1 or #2 pizza in the city. South Park original has the best patio.
We use cookies for essential site functions and, with your permission, for analytics and advertising. California residents can opt out of the sale or sharing of personal information at any time. See our Privacy Policy, Cookie Policy, and Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information.
San Diego Food Guide
Where is the best pizza in San Diego? Buona Forchetta, Bronx Pizza, Pizzeria Luigi, Cloak & Petal-adjacent Little Italy spots and Regents Pizzeria lead San Diego's pizza scene. Buona Forchetta is the benchmark for Neapolitan wood-fired pies; Bronx Pizza in Hillcrest is the New York-style slice standard.
Source: Sandi Spots — Last updated
San Diego's pizza scene punches well above its reputation — a Naples-certified Neapolitan crew, real-deal Detroit shops, a legit NY slice tradition, and a wave of California sourdough pizza. Here's the actual ranking for 2026.
Last updated
Quick answer: For Neapolitan: Buona Forchetta or Napizza. For NY slices: Regents Pizzeria (UTC) or Bronx Pizza (Hillcrest). For Detroit: Square Pizza Co. For California sourdough: Tribute Pizza. For late-night: Bronx Pizza or Basic Bar & Pizza in East Village.
AVPN-certified Neapolitan; consistently ranked #1 or #2 pizza in the city. South Park original has the best patio.
Rectangular Roman-style pizza (pizza al taglio). Order by the weight — get 2 or 3 slices to try.
The best straight-up NY slice in San Diego. Foldable, greasy in the right way.
Cash only, no substitutions, no attitude. One of SD's oldest classic NY slice shops.
California-sourdough style in an old post-office space. Wildly consistent.
The best Detroit-style in the county. Get the cup-and-char pepperoni.
The Detroit original that popularized Detroit-style pizza — outpost in Del Mar.
Late-night thin-crust in a converted warehouse. Serves until 2 AM on weekends.
Italian-owned Neapolitan on India Street. Consistent, walk-in friendly.
One of the OG craft-beer + pizza pairings in SD. Draft list is world-class.
Not a pizzeria per se, but their wood-fired seasonal pies compete with the top Neapolitans.
Coronado go-to for Roman-style; sit outdoors for the Coronado village vibe.
New wave of retro-80s NYC style; consistent trending pick.
Thick Sicilian squares and by-the-slice service. Cheap and generous.
Italian-owned wood-fired in Barrio Logan. Small dining room; reservations help.
Neighborhood spot with excellent thin-crust pies and a strong wine list.
Beach-town institution — craft beer brewed on-site, thin-crust pizza. Best casual pizza-and-a-pint in the county.
North Park + South Park
Buona Forchetta (Neapolitan), Tribute (sourdough), Square (Detroit), Pizza Cassette (NYC retro).
Little Italy + Downtown
Napizza (Roman al taglio), Isola Pizza Bar (Neapolitan), Basic (thin-crust, late night).
La Jolla + UTC
Regents (NY slices), Napizza La Jolla (Roman).
Coastal North County
Square Pizza Co. Encinitas (Detroit), Pizza Port Solana Beach + Bressi Ranch, Buddy's Del Mar (Detroit).
Coronado / Point Loma
Roman Cucina Coronado, Pizza Port Ocean Beach.
Neapolitan pies are meant to be eaten immediately — no leftovers. Detroit and Sicilian squares reheat perfectly.
AVPN certification (Buona Forchetta) means the pizzeria meets Naples' official Neapolitan standards.
For a big group, order two styles from the same restaurant — split a Margherita + a spicy pie.
Late-night pizza: Basic (E. Village) until 2 AM weekends, Bronx Pizza (Hillcrest) until 1 AM.
Best pizza-and-a-beer combo in the county: Pizza Port Solana Beach on a sunny weekday afternoon.
For overall consensus, Buona Forchetta (South Park) — AVPN-certified Neapolitan, consistently ranked #1 or #2 by every major SD food publication. For NY slices, Regents Pizzeria. For Detroit, Square Pizza Co.
Regents Pizzeria (UTC) is the top pick for foldable, greasy-in-a-good-way NY slices. Bronx Pizza (Hillcrest) is the classic cash-only slice shop. Pizza Cassette (North Park) is the modern retro-NYC take. Sicilian Thing Pizza is your Sicilian square option.
Square Pizza Co. (Encinitas + North Park) is the local Detroit-style leader — the pepperoni cup-and-char is the move. Buddy's Pizza (Del Mar) is the outpost of the Detroit original that popularized the style.
Buona Forchetta (South Park + 4 others) — AVPN-certified. Isola Pizza Bar (Little Italy) is the walk-in-friendly third pick.
Regents Pizzeria (UTC), Bronx Pizza (Hillcrest), Napizza (Little Italy, Roman-style al taglio), and Sicilian Thing Pizza (South Park). Napizza is best for lunch grabbing 2–3 slices in different flavors.
The Sandi Spots Newsletter
New beach finds, hidden taco shops, weekend events, and seasonal guides — once a week from a local. No spam, ever.
One email a week. Unsubscribe anytime.
Narrow it down to your neighborhood — locals' top pizza picks, block by block.
Written and fact-checked by the Sandi Spots Editorial team — San Diego residents publishing under Sleep Coast LLC. Every place we recommend has been visited in person or verified against an official source, and no business can pay for inclusion or a higher ranking. Last updated .