Order: Cheese slice + garlic knot $4–5/slice
Cash-only classic NY slice shop. No substitutions, no attitude, one of SD's oldest.
We use cookies for essential site functions and, with your permission, for analytics and advertising. California residents can opt out of the sale or sharing of personal information at any time. See our Privacy Policy, Cookie Policy, and Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information.
Old Town Local Guide
The best pizza in Old Town start with Bronx Pizza and Buona Forchetta. Here's where locals actually go in 2026, what to order, and what you'll pay.
Last updated
Quick answer: Top picks: Bronx Pizza, Buona Forchetta, Napizza.
Cash-only classic NY slice shop. No substitutions, no attitude, one of SD's oldest.
AVPN-certified Neopolitan. Consistently ranked #1 or #2 pizza in the city. South Park original has the best patio.
Rectangular Roman-style pizza sold by weight. Order 2–3 slices to try different flavors.
The best straight-up NY slice in San Diego. Foldable, greasy in the right way.
California-sourdough style in a converted post office. Wildly consistent and creative.
Neapolitan pies are meant to be eaten immediately — no leftovers.
AVPN certification means the pizzeria meets Naples' official Neapolitan standards.
Late-night pizza: Basic (East Village) until 2 AM weekends, Bronx Pizza (Hillcrest) until 1 AM.
For a group, split a Margherita and a spicy pie from the same menu.
Best pizza-and-a-beer combo: Pizza Port Solana Beach on a sunny weekday afternoon.
In Old Town, Bronx Pizza is the local anchor for pizza.
The best pizza in Old Town include Bronx Pizza, Buona Forchetta, Napizza. Bronx Pizza is the top local pick for Cheese slice + garlic knot, priced $4–5/slice.
Locals point to Bronx Pizza as the best pizza in Old Town — Cash-only classic NY slice shop. No substitutions, no attitude, one of SD's oldest.
Expect $4–5/slice to $16–24 per person at the top pizza spots in Old Town. Prices are current for 2026.
Yes — Old Town has pizza options that work for visitors, including Bronx Pizza, Buona Forchetta, Napizza. Most are casual and don't require a reservation, though weekend brunch and omakase counters are exceptions.
Neighborhood-level rankings for food, drinks, and coffee in Old Town.
Narrow it down to your neighborhood — locals' top pizza picks, block by block.
The Sandi Spots Newsletter
New beach finds, hidden taco shops, weekend events, and seasonal guides — once a week from a local. No spam, ever.
One email a week. Unsubscribe anytime.
Written and fact-checked by the Sandi Spots Editorial team — San Diego residents publishing under Sleep Coast LLC. Every place we recommend has been visited in person or verified against an official source, and no business can pay for inclusion or a higher ranking. Last updated .