Bencotto Italian Kitchen
Little Italy · $$$ · Pick pasta plus sauce
Fresh pasta made in house with a build-your-own format — choose the shape, choose the sauce. Reliable, unfussy and the neighborhood's most repeatable dinner.
Best Italian Restaurants in San Diego
Little Italy is a real neighborhood with a real fishing history — and some of the best pasta is outside it.
Last updated
Quick answer
Little Italy is the obvious place to eat Italian in San Diego, and it earns it: Bencotto and Monello for handmade pasta, Born & Raised's neighbors for the atmosphere, and Prep Kitchen and Herb & Wood on the higher end. But the best pasta in the county is often outside Little Italy — Cucina Urbana in Bankers Hill (with a retail wine wall priced near cost), Cori Pastificio Trattoria in Bay Park for small-batch fresh pasta, and Solare in Liberty Station for Sicilian cooking. For pizza, Buona Forchetta (Neapolitan, wood-fired, several locations) and Cloak & Petal-adjacent modern spots lead. Little Italy is busiest Wednesday and Saturday, when the farmers' market takes over Date Street.
Italian by neighborhood
| Restaurant | Specialty | Area / price |
|---|---|---|
| Bencotto | Build-your-own fresh pasta | Little Italy · $$$ |
| Monello | Milanese small plates, aperitivo | Little Italy · $$$ |
| Cucina Urbana | Pasta plus a near-cost wine wall | Bankers Hill · $$$ |
| Cori Pastificio Trattoria | Small fresh-pasta counter | Bay Park · $$ |
| Solare Ristorante | Sicilian, live music | Liberty Station · $$$ |
| Buona Forchetta | Neapolitan wood-fired pizza | South Park and others · $$ |
| Civico 1845 | Calabrian, strong vegan menu | Little Italy · $$$ |
Little Italy
Twenty walkable blocks of restaurants, plus one of the best farmers' markets in California on Saturdays.
Monello
Little Italy · $$$ · Aperitivo hour
Bencotto's sibling next door, built around Milanese small plates and a genuine aperitivo hour. Best for grazing and drinks rather than a formal dinner.
Civico 1845
Little Italy · $$$ · Vegan menu equal to the regular one
Calabrian cooking with a full parallel plant-based menu — the rare Italian restaurant where a mixed table is genuinely easy.
Outside Little Italy
Where locals go when they don't want to pay for parking downtown.
Cucina Urbana
Bankers Hill · $$$ · Retail wine wall
Italian-inspired California cooking with a wine shop built into the dining room — pick any bottle off the wall and pay a small corkage over retail. The best wine value of any restaurant in the city.
Cori Pastificio Trattoria
Bay Park · $$ · Small room, book ahead
A tiny fresh-pasta shop turned trattoria. Limited seats, limited hours, and the pasta that local chefs name when asked.
Solare Ristorante
Liberty Station · $$$ · Live music some nights
Sicilian-leaning menu in a big Liberty Station space with a patio and a lounge. Easy free parking, which matters more than it should.
Pizza
San Diego's pizza scene has gotten seriously good in the last decade.
Buona Forchetta
South Park, Liberty Station, Coronado, Encinitas · $$ · Neapolitan
Wood-fired Neapolitan pies from an imported oven, a loud family-friendly patio and long weekend waits. The South Park original still has the best atmosphere.
Neighborhood slice shops
North Park, Ocean Beach, Pacific Beach · $ · Late night
New York-style by-the-slice counters that stay open past bar close. The right answer at 11pm, not at 7pm.
Planning notes
- • Little Italy street parking is metered until 8pm; the Ash Street and Kettner garages are the reliable options on weekend nights.
- • The Little Italy Mercato farmers' market runs Saturday mornings and closes Date Street — great to combine with an early lunch, bad if you're driving in.
- • Most Little Italy restaurants take reservations 30 days out; Friday and Saturday tables at 7pm go first.
- • Buona Forchetta and Cori do not scale for large groups — call ahead for parties over six.
Frequently asked
Is Little Italy in San Diego worth visiting?
Yes — it's a genuine 20-block neighborhood with dense restaurant options, a Saturday farmers' market that's among the best in California, and a walkable waterfront edge. It's also the most reliable dinner neighborhood downtown.
What is the best Italian restaurant in San Diego?
Bencotto for handmade pasta in Little Italy, Cucina Urbana in Bankers Hill for the overall experience and wine value, and Cori Pastificio Trattoria in Bay Park for the best pasta in a small room.
Where is the best pizza in San Diego?
Buona Forchetta for wood-fired Neapolitan across several neighborhoods, with the South Park original the pick for atmosphere. Late-night slice shops in North Park and the beach towns cover the after-bar craving.
Do I need reservations in Little Italy?
For 6–8pm on Friday or Saturday, yes — book a week or two ahead. Weeknights and late seatings are usually walk-in friendly, and the bar seats at most rooms are first come, first served.
Keep reading
The Sandi Spots Newsletter
San Diego, in your inbox.
New beach finds, hidden taco shops, weekend events, and seasonal guides — once a week from a local. No spam, ever.
One email a week. Unsubscribe anytime.